Man beaten by sheikh sues Swiss

A man who claims he was whipped by a UAE sheikh is taking Switzerland to the European Court of Human Rights after Swiss courts acquitted his attacker.

Silvano Orsi says Sheikh Falah al-Nahyan used a belt to beat him after he rejected a gift of a bottle of champagne at a hotel in Geneva in 2003.

He was initially convicted of actual bodily harm, but was acquitted by Switzerland's highest court last month.

Mr Orsi says the later ruling infringed his human rights and was a cover-up.

Last year, Sheikh Falah, the brother of UAE President and Abu Dhabi ruler Sheikh Khalifa bin Zayed al-Nahyan, was found guilty of the attack on Mr Orsi at the La Reserve hotel and ordered to pay a fine of 10,000 Swiss francs (£4,930, $9,820).

But in October, his lawyers successfully argued at the Swiss Federal Tribunal that under Swiss law the offence of actual bodily harm could only be proved if it was carried out with a "dangerous object".

The metal-buckled belt their client used to whip Mr Orsi did not qualify and so the conviction was overturned, Mr Orsi said.

At the time of the incident it was reported that Sheikh Falah's lawyers had said it happened because their client was offended by Mr Orsi's suggestion that the champagne was a sexual advance.

Mr Orsi, a US citizen, argues that the Federal Tribunal's verdict breached his human rights, guaranteed under the European Convention on Human Rights, which Switzerland has ratified.

He says that he was the victim of global politics, because neither the US or Swiss governments wanted to annoy the United Arab Emirates.

"They are demonstrating their apparent willingness to ignore my human rights as an American in order to protect the newly proposed US-UAE 123 nuclear technology agreement that is currently before the US Congress," Mr Orsi told the BBC.

Sheikh Falah could not immediately be reached for comment. He has maintained his innocence in the past.

In response to recent police brutality incidents, HELEM, the Lebanese LGBT organization organized a demonstration in Beirut yesterday...

this is the first ever protest of this kind in the region....

Check out the video:

Helem board member and fundraiser Shadi Ghrawi: “It is a great honour to be selected. We hope it will help advance the struggle for human rights for LGBTI people in Lebanon, and throughout the Middle East.”
photo courtesy IGLHRC

NEW YORK, January 23, 2009 – Helem, the first organisation in the Arab world to set up a gay and lesbian community centre, has won this year’s Felipa de Souza Award, the International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission (IGLHRC) announced today.

Based in Beirut, Lebanon, Helem was founded in 2004.

“Helem works in very challenging circumstances to make a very real difference to the lives of countless LGBTI people in the Middle East and beyond,” IGLHRC executive director Paula Ettlebrick said this afternoon.

“We applaud their courage and commitment to human rights for all.”

The organisation’s work is multifaceted, ranging from advocacy to public education.

A major focus of its human rights advocacy work revolves around eradicating Article 534 of the Lebanese Penal Code, which is used to criminalise homosexuality; another advocacy focus addresses HIV/AIDS.

Its community centre has consistently offered the local LGBTI community a wide range of services ranging from HIV testing and counselling to workshops and publications about how to respond to harassment and arbitrary arrest.

“We are very proud to accept the Felipa Award from IGLHRC,” said Shadi Ghrawi, Helem board member and fundraiser.

“It is a great honour to be selected. We hope it will help advance the struggle for human rights for LGBTI people in Lebanon, and throughout the Middle East.”

The Felipa Award embodies the spirit of Felipa de Souza, who endured persecution and brutality after proudly declaring her intimacy with a woman during a 16th Century inquisition trial in Brazil.

Nominations for the award are solicited each year from activists around the world. Nominees go through a rigorous review by the staff, board and the International Advisory Committee of IGLHRC. This year IGLHRC received 23 nominations, and Helem was ultimately selected from a group of five, highly competitive finalists.

Previous Felipa Award winners include: Andrés Ignacio Rivera Duarte; the Iranian Queer Organization (IRQO); the Blue Diamond Society (BDS) of Nepal; Rauda Morcos, founder of ASWAT (Voices) the first group for Palestinian lesbians; Gays and Lesbians of Zimbabwe (GALZ), the first organization to push for the human rights of LGBT people in Zimbabwean society and to provide counseling services and HIV/AIDS prevention campaigns; Simon Tseko Nikoli, the famed LGBT/HIV activist from South Africa; Jamaica Forum for Lesbians, All-Sexuals and Gays, whose leader Brian Williamson was murdered in 2004; Lohana Berkins, a globally recognized transgender activist from Argentina; and Maher Sabry, the Egyptian activist who notified IGLHRC of the arrests of the Cairo 52, a group of 52 men who were arrested by the Egyptian police at a Cairo gay nightclub in 2001.

The Felipa Award will be presented to Helem as part of IGLHRC's A Celebration of Courage gala event on March 30, 2008 in New York and on April 2, 2008 in San Francisco.

Sheikh Falah Al Nahyan, the Gay brother of the UAE president has been found guilty in a Swiss court of beating a US citizen with a belt at a hotel bar in Geneva in 2003.

The tribunal fined the gay sheikh 10,000 Swiss francs (£4,930, $9,820). In addition he received a suspended penalty of 540,000 francs. The judgement said that the sheikh repeatedly hit Silvano Orsi with a steel-buckled belt.

The court said the sheikh inflicted "bodily harm with the use of a dangerous object" on Mr Orsi, a resident of Rochester, New York, after Mr Orsi declined an offer of a bottle of champagne from the sheikh.